YouTube Shooting Ignites Debate Over Merging Physical & IT Security

A woman shot and wounded three people at YouTubes headquarters on Tuesday, a tragic event that shines a light on the industrys long-running debate over whether physical and IT security departments should be merged under one roof.

YouTube employees fled the companys headquarters in terror Tuesday afternoon, as a woman, now identified as Nasim Najafi Aghdam, shot and wounded three people in the companys outdoor courtyard before killing herself.
Its not clear what drove Aghdam to target the companys headquarters in San Bruno, Calif., although the
New York Times noted
that she had criticized YouTubes policies.
At first blush,
this tragedy
may come across as something that only a companys physical security team should handle. But as more active shooter episodes erupt across the nation this year from the Parkland, Fla., attack that
killed 17 high school students
to the Yountville, Calif., veterans home attack that resulted in the
deaths of three people
and the shooter, more attention may be paid to the long-standing debate about merging IT security teams and physical security teams into one consolidated department, according to several experts.
YouTubes headquarters in San Bruno, Calif.

(Source:
Wikimedia
)
Most businesses today are relying on human intervention in order to mitigate these situations and security alerts. The use of technology to augment these situations is more important than ever, Tony Ball, vice president and general manager of identity and access management for Entrust Datacard, told Security Now.
Technology has now enabled people to have a physical and digital footprint, Ball added. And these footprints indicate whether or not a person should be in a certain location or in a certain situation. These footprints, as a result, can alert security -- either physical or IT-based -- to shut down an access point, whether a physical door or a system, Ball said.
Active shooter challenges
In the case of April 3 YouTube incident, the shooter is believed to have entered an open, less secure area where employees could gather to eat their lunch. Because a secured, physical perimeter was not likely breached, there would have been no security alerts to send to the IT security team, who in turn could have sent the physical security staff to investigate, security experts theorized.
However, Ball notes there may be situations that do arise where an active shooter enters an area that is more secure and that is the time converged IT security and physical security teams would greatly benefit being part of the same team.
For example, an active shooter is more than likely carrying a mobile device. This device can say a lot about the shooter, such as where the person has been, whether or not person has been in a certain location previously, or whether or not the person exhibited certain behaviors, Ball explains.
Once a security team knows who this person is via their digital footprint, the IT security team can choose to increase or decrease their risk level based on these characteristics, Ball said. An integrated security team can either physically send security personnel to intervene in the situation or disable access privileges via connected IT security and physical access systems, he added, noting that the device can help security personnel locate an individual based on global location services embedded in the device.
Additionally, if biometric measures are in place, when a known, or unknown person, enters a perimeter, cameras can detect if the individual should be there or not, Ball said. If they are allowed certain access privileges, the security team can allow entry. If the individual is not supposed to be in that location, the security team can challenge the request for access by increasing the physical or digital security measures.
Other tools and processes organizations may want to consider for their converged security teams are a common identity management system, video analytics and a single governance body for the merged security team, according to Cisco Systems white paper
Why Integrate Physical and Logical Security?

A long debate
Both physical and IT security departments have been talking about convergence for more than ten years, Michael Gips, chief global knowledge and learning officer for ASIS International, told Security Now. He noted the use of physical security devices getting placed routinely on corporate networks accelerated the discussion of convergence.
And in 2010, ASISs CSO Roundtable, which is now called the CSO Center, found 10% to 15% of large companies they surveyed had reported that they fully converged their IT security and physical security departments. That percentage, however, largely did not change when a subsequent survey was conducted in 2014, Gips said.
The fundamentals of network security are being redefined -- dont get left in the dark by a DDoS attack! Join us in Austin from May 14-16 at the fifth annual
Big Communications Event
. Theres still time to register and communications service providers get in free!
Several issues, however, are preventing more organizations from merging their security teams.
IT and physical security professionals have complementary skills, which makes convergence seem to be a logical solution, Gips said. But both sides think they should be running the converged department.
Some team members are also worried that the word converged is synonymous with lay-offs, which is a threat, he explained. And lastly, IT security and physical security professionals often report up through entirely different lines, Gips says. IT security reports into IT, operations or administration departments, while physical security team members tend to report into legal, facilities or human resource departments, says Gips.
Convergence, thus, would require organizational surgery, so to speak, he says. But a lot of security people think wide-scale convergence is inevitable because of the presumed cost savings to companies.
Related posts:
Android Crypto Mining Attacks Go for Monero
Rogue Employees Mine Cryptocurrency Using Company Hardware
Saks Fifth Avenue, Lord & Taylor Hit With Massive Data Breach
— Dawn Kawamoto is an award-winning technology and business journalist, whose work has appeared in CNETs News.com, Dark Reading, TheStreet.com, AOLs DailyFinance, and The Motley Fool
.

Last News
▸ Travel agency fined £150,000 for breaking Data Protection Act. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ 7 arrested, 3 more charged in StubHub cyber fraud ring. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ Nigerian scammers now turning into mediocre malware pushers. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
YouTube Shooting Ignites Debate Over Merging Physical & IT Security