Researcher Pokes Holes In Java 7 Security

Programmer questions Java 7 security model, details hacks that allow faked app locations and server redirects.

Is the design of Oracles Java 7 security sandbox backwards?
That charge was leveled by programmer Jerry Jongerius, who last week released a Java Code Signing Failure alert detailing how Java security dialog boxes could be
hacked to display arbitrary app names
, even if the app had been digitally signed.
Jongerius, who programs in Java and runs a software development firm called Duckware, has been busy since then. In recent days, hes detailed a technique for tricking the Java security dialog box into displaying not only a fake app name, but also a false location, such as www.java.com. He also found a way to redirect an app thats
sandboxed
-- meaning that its range of activities should be restricted -- to
accept commands from an arbitrary server
.
In addition, he found a way to trick Java 6 and Java 7 into allowing a sandboxed Java applet to
retrieve any photo stored on a computer
by using the Applet.getImage() command built into Java. I leave it as an exercise for Oracle to determine if Applet.getAudioClip() is also vulnerable, he said.
[ For more on recent Java vulnerabilities, see
Java Malicious App Alert System Tricked
. ]
One mitigating factor for that image-retrieval vulnerability, however, is that anyone who might want to abuse the flaw must know the name of the file to be retrieved. Accordingly, he said, the real-world risk to users from the flaws that hes identified would be minimal.
Jongerius said hes reported all of the new vulnerabilities to the U.S. Computer Emergency Response Team (CERT), but not directly to Oracle. No word from CERT or Oracle, he said Thursday via email.
But Jongerius efforts apparently havent gone unnoticed. For starters, he saw traffic come to his site from CERT -- as well as from a military domain -- after he filed his getImage() bug report. In addition, he reported receiving a
rude message
via his websites contact page from an IP address that traced to an Oracle facility in Dallas.
An Oracle spokeswoman, contacted by email, didnt immediately respond to a request for comment on that allegation, whether the company was aware of Jongerius research and had verified the vulnerability reports, or if it had fixes in the works.
Beyond finding multiple vulnerabilities in Java 7, Jongerius also raised some bigger-picture questions about the efficacy and code quality behind the
Java security model
, which allows digitally signed apps to request permissions that are denied outright to sandboxed apps, such as accessing an image on the PC, accessing the clipboard or executing code.
A fundamental rule in security is that code must ask for only the minimum permissions needed to run and no more, Jongerius said.
But Java 7 doesnt allow signed apps to be sandboxed. If you try to be a very conscientious software developer and request that your Java applet be run in the Java security sandbox -- so you cannot access the local computer... the Java VM will erroneously block your applet from even running, he said.
Yet Oracle has been pushing Java users to
use only signed Java applications
. Notably, Java 7 update 21, released in April, added a warning system designed to deter people from running any unsigned app, backed by a stern caution for unsigned code that running this application may be a security risk. Based on Jongerius research, that warning message isnt triggered by any type of code scan but is based purely on whether the app has been signed.
But even
signed apps can be malicious
, CERT Coordination Center vulnerability analyst Will Dormann
has long warned
. Accordingly, Dormann has argued that Java 7 users would be best served by using only unsigned apps.
A poorly designed sandboxed Java applet cant do much of anything, he said in an April
Dont Sign That Applet blog post
. However, a poorly designed signed Java applet can do pretty much anything that native code can.
The underlying problem, Dormann explained, is that digitally signing an app is no guarantee that its safe. Java conflates authentication (Who wrote this code?) with authorization (What is this code allowed to do?). When you sign an applet, it gets privileges automatically, he said.
What would be better, both Dormann and Jongerius argue, is that a Java applet should be signed only if it requests permissions that might have security repercussions, such as access to the local file system. Otherwise, all apps should be sandboxed by default. Furthermore, even signed apps should be restricted to receiving only requested permissions, rather than gaining all-you-can-eat access. Jongerius said that such restrictions are in place for Java apps run from Web servers, but they
can be bypassed for apps that run locally
.
That research aside, its important to remember that numerous security experts have recommended
disabling the Java Web browser plug-in
altogether, whenever possible. If you dont need Java in your Web browser, turn it off, said Dormann. If you dont know if you need Java in your Web browser, turn it off anyway and see what breaks. You might find that it doesnt affect you at all.
For anyone who does need to use Java, the prevailing information security wisdom is to always update immediately to the latest version, since it will mitigate a number of well-known and widely exploited vulnerabilities.
But according to research published Wednesday by security firm Websense, while 84% of browsers today have Java enabled, last month
only 19% of enterprise Windows PCs
were running Java 7 update 25, which was released in June and remains the most recent version. Meanwhile, over 40% of Java traffic from enterprises came from Java 6 clients, which Oracle ceased patching in April and which is increasingly an
attack magnet
for hackers and crimeware kits.

Last News
▸ ArcSight prepares for future at user conference post HP acquisition. ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Samsung Epic 4G: First To Use Media Hub ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Many third-party software fails security tests ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
Researcher Pokes Holes In Java 7 Security