Perceptual Ad Blockers Have Security Flaws, Too

Blocking ads is more than stopping annoying pop-ups. Theres a security component as well. However, a crop of perceptual ad blockers that use machine learning have their own flaws and shortcomings.

Users want to be able to block the ads that show up on websites for more reasons than not wanting to be annoyed by the content. They also wish to protect themselves from the malicious content that may be embedded within those ads.
Typical ad blockers currently in use are based on filter lists, which are specifics that tell the ad blockers exactly what type of content to block.
However, there are problems with this approach, notably keeping that list current and relevant.
This led researchers at Princeton University
to develop what they called a perceptual ad blocker over the course of 18 months.
Essentially, it looks at the web page, and deletes ads based on what it sees.
It was hoped that this kind of approach would stop the arms race of ad generators making minor tweaks in their ads to stop the blocking actions, which was then followed by ad blockers responding with new lists, and then ad generators making further tweaks.
(Source:
iStock
)
Perceptual blockers are designed to pick up on structural ad cues like a Sponsored link or a close button inside of a pop-up ads, as well as any legally required signifiers an ad must show. They will use these structural elements to make the blocking decision.
But security researchers from Stanford University and CISPA Helmholtz Center for Information Security have found some conceptual and practical problems with this approach.
Their research paper
finds that they have found ways that such a blocker not only can be definitively defeated, but may pose security problems.
As the researchers note:

We show that perceptual ad-blocking engenders a new arms race that likely disfavors ad-blockers. Unexpectedly, perceptual ad-blocking can also introduce new vulnerabilities that let an attacker bypass web security boundaries and mount DDoS attacks.

The researchers looked at two perceptual ad blockers.
The first is named Perceptual Ad Highlighter and the other is called Sentinel. Both use neural networks to do the training needed for the blockers to learn what an ad looks like. From this training, the blockers create a model of what they expect an ad to look like. This model is then used for the block or leave alone decision.
To attack the perceptual blockers, the researchers first created ads that were designed to fool both of the blockers. They made changes to the form of the ads that were imperceptible to a human, but capable of fooling a machine learning algorithm.
One change they made was to alter the AdChoices logo commonly found in ads. They also found that a transparent mask laid over a website could do the trick as well. The researchers also looked at other possible attacks.
However, in the end, they found that current ways of developing perceptual ad blockers were not going to survive a determined adversary. The researchers feel that the methods that are currently in use to train such blockers are easily hoodwinked.
As the researchers summarized:

The overarching goal of this analysis has been to highlight and raise awareness of the fundamental vulnerabilities that perceptual ad-blockers inherit from existing vision classifiers. As long as robust defenses to adversarial examples elude us, perceptual ad-blockers will be dragged into a new arms race in which they start from a precariously disadvantaged position -- given the stringent threat model that they must survive.

Related posts:
NordVPN & ProtonVPN Offerings Vulnerable to Code Execution Attack
IAM Heads to the Mobile Cloud
Sophisticated Malvertising Campaign Involves 10,000 WordPress Sites
Mobile Malware Increases, While Hiding in Porn Sites
— Larry Loeb has written for many of the last centurys major dead tree computer magazines, having been, among other things, a consulting editor for BYTE magazine and senior editor for the launch of WebWeek.

Last News
▸ Debunking Machine Learning in Security. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ Researchers create BlackForest to gather, link threat data. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ Travel agency fined £150,000 for breaking Data Protection Act. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
Perceptual Ad Blockers Have Security Flaws, Too