No Internet Access? Amid Protests, Heres How to Tell Whether the Government Is Behind it

Government-mandated Internet shutdowns occur far more regularly than you might expect.

Since the death of George Floyd at the hands of Minneapolis law enforcement on May 25, millions of people worldwide have taken to the streets to protest police violence. But one oft-used government tactic in some countries to limit the ability of their citizens to communicate and organize has been absent so far: There have been virtually no reports of state-mandated Internet shutdowns in response to the protest.
Part of the reason for that is its much harder to diagnose cellular connectivity problems when thousands of people flood into one neighborhood, all demanding to use mobile phone infrastructure that wasnt designed to handle so many devices at once. While one of the few instances of a US government-mandated network shutdown came in 2011 – when police for the BART transit system in the San Francisco Bay Area
shut down cellular service for several hours during protests
that followed multiple police shootings of passengers – this time around Seth Schoen, senior staff technologies at the Electronic Frontier Foundation, said his colleagues havent been able to confirm the rumors theyve heard about government interference of mobile networks.
I havent seen any hard evidence that couldnt also be easily explained by networks being overloaded, Schoen said in an email exchange. But in many cases, consumers can tell whether there has been government interference with Internet access because it will affect people on different parts of the Internet in different ways, he added.
Government-mandated Internet shutdowns occur far more regularly than you might expect. The number of countries that shut down access for their residents jumped from 25 in 2018 to 33 in 2019, according to the annual
Keep It On report
published in February by nonprofit Internet advocacy group Access Now. China, Vietnam, Egypt, Iran, Syria, and Cuba are notorious in this regard and regularly cited as countries with the least Internet freedom, according to 2019s
Freedom on the Net report
, produced annually by the US-based democracy and human rights nonprofit Freedom House. But theyre not the only countries that use Internet shutdowns to control the flow of information and ideas.
Among the worst offenders are India and Brazil. In the contested state of Kashmir, the Indian government blocked
all Internet access
, landlines, and mobile service for between August 2019 and March 2020. Brazil regularly
blocks access to the messaging service WhatsApp
, even as other Internet services in the country have continued unabated. Internet Research company Top10VPN estimated the cost of Internet shutdowns in 2019 to be
more than $8 billion globally
.
How to Discern
Despite politically driven interference, Internet monitoring organizations point to some telltale clues that can help people determine whether their sudden inability to use the Internet is a technical glitch, such as an underwater cable cut, a distributed denial-of-service (DDoS) attack, or a government-mandated order.
Most of the government-mandated Internet shutdowns or blocks are based on interfering with the countrys Domain Name System (DNS), the protocol that maps websites to IP addresses, says Arturo Filastò, project lead at the Open Observatory of Network Interference, a nonprofit that monitors and documents Internet shutdowns. Since most of the worlds DNS queries are resolved in plain text, Internet service providers can be convinced by the governments they operate under to restrict access to certain sites – or even all of them, he says.
DNS hijacking is most common in the West. Its the first level because its the easiest and cheapest, Filastò says. Another technique under the DNS tampering umbrella is DNS spoofing, such as the Chinese Great Firewall, where they will spoof the response to a DNS query faster than the legitimate response.
Measuring Internet connectivity and shutdowns has grown more sophisticated over the years. The Center for Applied Internet Data Analysis at the University of California, San Diego, uses a combination of global Internet routing, active probing of IP addresses, and the background radiation from the Internet itself to evaluate the cause of a shutdown.
Some measurements will tell you that the physical [Internet] connectivity still exists during a shutdown. One of our three methods will still see the existence of connectivity, says Alberto Dainotti, research scientist with the
Internet Outage Detection and Analysis group
at CAIDA.
Determining whether a shutdown is caused by a technical snafu, a DDoS attack, or government interference can be tricky. If you cant reach a website but others in your country can, its most likely a technical issue with your network. (T-Mobile users experienced this in North America
last week
.) If all or most websites work for you but one specific one appears to be down, it could be a targeted attack (by malicious hackers or a government order) focused on that one site. Specific websites can be checked with the service
Down for Everyone or Just Me
.
Of course, it can also be a government shutdown. Several services can help Internet users identify when their service is being disrupted by a DDoS attack or a government shutdown. In its
Surveillance Self-Defense guide
, the EFF recommends using encrypted DNS, a virtual private network, or the Tor Browser to circumvent DNS-based network shutdowns. Filastòs employer also offers its
OONI Probe
to help users test network connectivity and identify likely reasons for the shutdown theyre experiencing.
The EFFs Schoen noted consumers should be more worried about technical problems on their devices or with their ISPs before presuming their government is blocking part or all of their Internet access – even though government-initiated Internet interference and shutdowns are on the rise.
Governments do actively tamper with peoples devices and network connections, but less frequently than random errors and outages that arent intentional on anyones part, he said.
Related Content:
Cloud Threats and Priorities as We Head Into the Second Half of 2020
Cyber Subterfuge and Curious Sharks Threaten the World’s Subsea Fiber-Optic Cables
Black Hat Survey: Breach Concerns Hit Record Levels Due to COVID-19
Local, State Governments Face Cybersecurity Crisis
How Cybersecurity Incident Response Programs Work (and Why Some Dont)

Learn from industry experts in a setting that is conducive to interaction and conversation about how to prepare for that really bad day in cybersecurity. Click for
more information and to register
for this On-Demand event.

Last News
▸ ArcSight prepares for future at user conference post HP acquisition. ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Samsung Epic 4G: First To Use Media Hub ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Many third-party software fails security tests ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
No Internet Access? Amid Protests, Heres How to Tell Whether the Government Is Behind it