NISTs Hash Algorithm Refresh Possibly Premature

Security expert Bruce Schneier says theres really no need for the upcoming SHA-3 standard

The National Institute of Standards & Technology (NIST) is set to announce the winning hash algorithm that ultimately will become the next-generation industry standard, SHA-3. But security expert Bruce Schneier, whose own solution is among the five finalists, says theres really no need for a new hash standard right now because the old one is doing just fine, thank you.
After a spate of SHA-cracking targeting earlier versions of the standard, NIST was under the gun to keep the algorithm strong. When we started this process [in 2006], we did think the whole SHA familys days were numbered, Schneier says. But then the SHA hacks stopped.
The most recent version of the algorithm for fingerprinting messages and files, SHA-512, so far has held up. That, and the fact that none of the finalist versions are exponentially better solutions means it makes more sense to stick with SHA-512 for now, Schneier says.
Theyre all OK, but theres no compelling reason to switch, he says. Thats in contrast to the Advanced Encryption Standard (AES), which, when it was announced, was widely adopted to replace the slower and outdated Data Encryption Standard (DES).
NIST was
scheduled to announce the winning specification
for SHA-3 in the second quarter of this year, but hasnt done so yet. The submission and selection process began in late 2007, and some 64 entries were part of the first round of the competition. The algorithm converts messages into shorter message digests that can be used in digital signatures and message authentication, for example.
[Researchers with IBM highlighted the deteriorating state of password security in the IBM X-Force 2012 Mid-year Trend and Risk Report. See
Bashing The Hash: IBM X-Force On Password Follies
.]
Schneier, who
blogged
about SHA-3 today, says his submission, Skein, is among the finalists. But even so, he still believes SHA-512 is sufficient and doesnt require a substitution right now.
That doesnt mean SHA-512 wont ultimately be broken. I dont know if we have tried hard enough to break SHA-512, he says. And just because it hasnt happened yet doesnt mean there hasnt been multiple attempts, he says.
Robert Graham, CEO of Errata Security, concurs that SHA-512 is doing the job today. SHA-512 is doing well. There are some threats to it, but thats just because its really well-understood, Graham says. SHA-3 wont be well-understood -- there is a good chance that a couple years after adoption, there will be just as many threats as with SHA-512.
Even so, says Graham, SHA-512 is not widely adopted today. I dont see it in hardware, and software has become incredibly modular, making it easy to plug in SHA-3. After a couple of years, SHA-3 will be just as widely spread as SHA-512, Graham says.
He says the benefits of faster hashing and other features with SHA-3 will ultimately make it worth the transition.
Schneier, meanwhile, says hell recommend sticking with SHA-512 for now. ...None of the SHA-3 candidates is significantly better. Some are faster, but not orders of magnitude faster. Some are smaller in hardware, but not orders of magnitude smaller. When SHA-3 is announced, Im going to recommend that, unless the improvements are critical to their application, people stick with the tried and true SHA-512. At least for a while, he wrote in his post.
So what about Skein? Well, maybe theres one reason NIST should choose Skein. Skein isnt just a hash function, its the large-block cipher Threefish and a mechanism to turn it into a hash function. I think the world actually needs a large-block cipher, and if NIST chooses Skein, well get one, he wrote.
Have a comment on this story? Please click Add Your Comment below. If youd like to contact
Dark Readings
editors directly,
send us a message
.

Last News
▸ ArcSight prepares for future at user conference post HP acquisition. ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Samsung Epic 4G: First To Use Media Hub ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Many third-party software fails security tests ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
NISTs Hash Algorithm Refresh Possibly Premature