Facebook Settles Lawsuit Over Sponsored Stories

Proposes paying $10 million to settle class action lawsuit over using Facebook users names and images in advertising without their permission.

Facebooks History: From Dorm To IPO Darling (click image for larger view and for slideshow)
Facebook has proposed paying $10 million to settle a class action lawsuit over its use of Facebook users images and names in its Sponsored Stories advertising campaigns.
Before becoming final, however, the
proposed settlement
must first be approved by a federal judge.
The settlement relates to a
class action lawsuit
first filed in U.S. District Court in California in March 2011 by Angel Fraley, Paul Wang, and Susan Mainzer, as well as two minors named only by their initials (J.H.D. and W.T.). It alleged that Facebooks use of its users images for advertising purposes--without compensation--had caused them economic harm.
[ For more on Facebook and privacy concerns, see
Facebook Buys Face.com: At What Privacy Cost?
]
At issue here is one of Facebooks advertising practices in particular, Sponsored Stories, which appear on a members Facebook page, and which typically consist of another members name, profile picture, and an assertion that the person likes the advertiser, coupled with the advertisers logo, read court documents filed in support of the lawsuit. Sponsored Stories are generated when a member interacts with the Facebook website or affiliated sites in certain ways, such as by clicking on the Like button on a companys Facebook page.
After the lawsuit was first filed, Facebook issued the following statement: We are reviewing the decision and continue to believe that the case is without merit. Facebook also sought to distinguish its Sponsored Stories from advertising. For example, last year in an
interview with the BBC
, Facebook public policy VP Elliot Schrage explained to BBC reporter Emily Maitlis the process by which clicking the Like button could lead to users names or images being used in Sponsored Stories. When I press a Like button on an ad, Im trying on the Facebook system, I am affirmatively communicating that I am associating myself with whatever Im liking. And what that does is create a story, he said.
Well, you can call it a story--many people would call it an advertisement--and Facebook is getting paid for those by the companies, responded Maitlis.
Interestingly, the presiding judge in the
Fraley versus Facebook case
appeared to agree. California has long recognized a right to protect ones name and likeness against appropriation by others for their advantage, U.S. District Judge Lucy Koh
wrote in a December 2011 ruling
that granted and denied parts of a motion filed by Facebook to dismiss the lawsuit.
Koh ruled that Facebooks interpretation that its Like button constituted a consumer endorsement of any product or service, allowing their name or likeness to be used for free in advertising, potentially violated Californias
Right of Privacy Law
.
The plaintiffs argued--under the states Right of Privacy Law--that they were economically injured by having their names and likenesses used without compensation. But Facebook, in its motion to dismiss the case, argued that because the Facebook users werent celebrities, they should first have to demonstrate that had some preexisting commercial value to their names and likenesses, according to court documents. Koh dismissed that argument, noting that under California law, residents didnt have to be celebrities to suffer economic injury when their name, voice, signature, photograph, or likeness was used without their consent.
The plaintiffs also argued that
Facebooks privacy policy
led them to believe they have control over Facebooks use of their likeness in advertising such as Sponsored Stories, according to court documents.
But actually opting out of Sponsored Stories isnt a straightforward process. Members are unable to opt out of the Sponsored Stories service, which was introduced after Plaintiffs became Facebook members, and instructions on how to disable an individual post from appearing on Friends News Feeds or as a Sponsored Story are only available on a buried Help Center page, not connected by any link within the Privacy Policy or Statement of Rights and Responsibilities pages, wrote Koh in her ruling.
Facebook didnt immediately respond to a request for comment about what changes the company might make in the wake of the proposed settlement, such as
altering its data use policy
or discontinuing its practice of using members names and images as part of Sponsored Stories should they click the Like button for a company, brand, or product.
Facebooks proposed settlement would distribute $10 million not to users, but rather to groups whose charters set out actions and programs relevant to advocacy related to the purposes for which the case was brought. The settlement focused on that type of a payout after finding that any type of compensation for affected members would be not practicable, wrote Edward A. Infante, the retired Chief Magistrate Judge of the U.S. District Court who mediated the settlement agreement. For example, any damages awarded under the California Right of Publicity Law could involve a minimum of $750 per person affected, which, if applied to all Facebook users, would result in a fine of $75 billion.
New apps promise to inject social features across entire workflows, raising new problems for IT. In the new, all-digital
Social Networking
issue of InformationWeek, find out how companies are making social networking part of the way their employees work. Also in this issue: How to better manage your video data. (Free with registration.)

Last News
▸ 7 arrested, 3 more charged in StubHub cyber fraud ring. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ Nigerian scammers now turning into mediocre malware pushers. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ Beware EMV may not fully protect against skilled thieves. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
Facebook Settles Lawsuit Over Sponsored Stories