Facebook Declines Bug Bounty, But Crowdsourced Effort Pays

Security researchers, unhappy with Facebooks decision to withhold reward, come up with the cash on their own.

10 Facebook Features To Help You Get Ahead (click image for larger view)
If Facebook wont pay a bug bounty to a security researcher who attempted to responsibly report a serious vulnerability -- only to be hampered by poor communication on the social networks part -- then we will.
Thats the message from the information security community -- and fans -- which have banded together to crowdsource a $10,000 reward for Palestinian security researcher Khalil Shreateh, after Facebook
declined to compensate him
as part of its White Hat security program. Facebook said that Shreateh violated its bug-reporting
terms of service
after he used the vulnerability to bypass the sites security controls and post a message on Facebook founder and CEO Mark Zuckerbergs wall.
But Marc Maiffret, CTO of BeyondTrust, criticized Facebook for missing the big picture: Shreatehs intentions were good, but he was hampered by Facebooks information security staff. Furthermore, Shreateh chose to report the vulnerability directly to the social network, instead of attempting to profit from it on the open market, where he stood to earn a substantially bigger payout.
Its a pretty significant bug, Maiffret
told CNN
. The vulnerability could be used to post messages -- including photos and links -- to anyones Facebook wall. It would have been something that was very useful to folks in the underground to be able to post different content on celebrity sites or whatever it might have been, to be able to lure people to websites that would then attack them.
[ Do you believe Facebook has no role in business? Better rethink that position:
Ignore Facebook At Your Peril
. ]
In Facebooks defense, Shreateh used a third-party users account to demonstrate the bug. But that was only after the social networks security team twice dismissed his attempt to report the vulnerability. Instead of offering clear guidance to Shreateh, furthermore, a Facebook security engineer said simply, I am sorry this is not a bug.
Recapping those events, Maiffret -- in an offhand comment -- told CNN that if Facebook wouldnt pay Shreateh, then hed be happy to help. If Mark Zuckerberg doesnt have the $2,000 to set this guy on the right path, if he contacts me Id be happy to do it personally, Maiffret said. Zuckerbergs net worth is estimated to be
$16.1 billion
.
In fact, Maiffret made good on his proposal later in the day, by donating $3,000 to Shreateh via a GoFundMe site campaign he created, which seeks to
pay Shreateh a $10,000 bug bounty
. All proceeds raised from this fund will be sent to Khalil Shreateh to help support future security research, according to the campaign page. Let us all send a message to security researchers across the world and say that we appreciate the efforts they make for the good of everyone. By Tuesday morning the campaign had already raised over $8,500, as well as offers of jobs for Shreateh, an information systems engineer who says hes unemployed.
Facebooks lack of largesse continues to draw widespread criticism, with one
InformationWeek
reader
commenting
: Facebook Zucks.
Late Monday, Facebooks chief security officer, Joe Sullivan, issued a mea culpa -- of sorts -- over the miscommunication with Shreateh. Ive reviewed our communication with this researcher, and I understand his frustration. He tried to report the bug responsibly, and we failed in our communication with him, said Sullivan in a
blog post
. We get hundreds of submissions a day, and only a tiny percent of those turn out to be legitimate bugs. As a result we were too hasty and dismissive in this case.
But Sullivan argued that the communication failure hadnt stemmed from a language barrier, or Facebook not being receptive to people sharing vulnerability details with the social network
in return for bug bounties
that pay a fraction of what researchers might receive on the
open vulnerability market
.
Rather, Sullivan said that Shreatehs emails had lacked sufficient technical detail. Accordingly, he promised that Facebook would update its White Hat page with recommendations for the best ways to report bugs -- hint: Facebook really likes videos that show the vulnerabilities in action -- as well as to improve our email messaging to make sure we clearly articulate what we need to validate a bug. He also noted that Facebook offers test accounts for any researcher that may want to demonstrate a vulnerability.
Sullivan added that Facebook stood firm on its refusal to compensate Shreateh. We will not change our practice of refusing to pay rewards to researchers who have tested vulnerabilities against real users, he said. We hope this case does not discourage this researcher or any other researcher from submitting future reports to us.

Last News
▸ IoT Devices on Average Have 25 Vulnerabilities ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ DHS-funded SWAMP scans code for bugs. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security	▸ Debunking Machine Learning in Security. ◂ Discovered: 23/12/2024 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
Facebook Declines Bug Bounty, But Crowdsourced Effort Pays