DoJ Narrows Scope of DreamHost Warrant

The Department of Justice has scaled back the demands of a search warrant served to web hosting provider DreamHost.

When most IT managers think about cybersecurity, theyre thinking about keeping their companys data safe from criminals and cyber-warfare opponents. Some service providers, most recently DreamHost, have expanded that list of adversaries to include the US Department of Justice. And on August 22, DreamHost scored a small victory in their most recent battle.
If you havent been following this particular part of the news, back in July the Department of Justice obtained
a federal warrant
ordering DreamHost to turn over everything they had regarding www.disruptj20.org, a site hosted on the companys computers. DreamHost declined, stating that to do so would mean giving the DoJ (among other things) the IP address, and therefore a huge hint about the identity, of everyone who had ever visited the site.
Since approximately 1.3 million people had visited the site, and only 239 were arrested in the protest organized by the site, DreamHost stated that this meant the Fourth Amendment rights of approximately 1.3 million people would be violated.
According to some legal analysis
, DreamHosts objections are unusual since a two-step warrant process is normal.
In this two-step process, the government asks for, and receives, everything possible from a provider, then sorts through the information and throws away everything not specific to the original warrant. DreamHost objected to providing the first step because of the political nature of the site.
Want to learn more about the technology and business opportunities and challenges for the cable industry in the commercial services market? Join Light Reading in New York on November 30 for the 11th annual
Future of Cable Business Services event
. All cable operators and other service providers get in free.
Yesterday, news broke that the Department of Justice has
scaled back its request for information
. In a
legal brief filed this morning
, the U.S. attorney for the District of Columbia, Channing Phillips, wrote, the Warrant was not intended to be used, and will not be used, to identify the political dissidents of the current administration[.]... Nor will it be used to chill... free association and the right of free speech afforded by the Constitution.
The brief then goes on to say, One of those challenges is that some of the evidence -- particularly the full scope of the evidence -- will be hidden from the governments view unless and until the government obtains a court order or search warrant. Translated into English, that means that the government doesnt know precisely what its looking for until it sees everything you have. While common in cyber-warrants, this is the opposite of the logic used in most physical evidence warrants.
The DoJ said that it didnt realize that, in asking for everything DreamHost had, it would get log files that included IP addresses and has no desire to identify those who simply visited the site. DreamHost, for its part,
stated in a blog post
that, while it welcomes the DoJs revisions, it doesnt believe they go far enough. DreamHost promises that it will lay out additional objections and seek further narrowing of the warrant in court proceedings on the morning of Thursday, August 24.
Disclosure: The author is a long-time customer of DreamHost and continues to host websites and email services with the company.
— Curtis Franklin is the editor of
SecurityNow.com
. Follow him on Twitter
@kg4gwa
.

Last News
▸ ArcSight prepares for future at user conference post HP acquisition. ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Samsung Epic 4G: First To Use Media Hub ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Many third-party software fails security tests ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps

News/Aarticles

Phishing Database

Deepfake Detection

Trends/Statistics & Live Infos

Tags:
DoJ Narrows Scope of DreamHost Warrant