AI: An Emerging Insider Threat?

As artificial intelligence increasingly gains a presence in the enterprise, concerns are already being raised of a new insider threat where AI will turn against its operators. How can security experts address this frenemy?

Machines being smarter than humans has already played out across national TV and the Internet, from IBMs supercomputer Watson defeating renowned
Jeopardy!
game contestants to Googles AlphaGo beating the worlds best Go game player.
And while the closely watched Jeopardy and
Go competitions
demonstrated how computers raised on machine learning and packed with artificial intelligence can surpass human intelligence and hold vast potential for delivering good to society, concerns have also emerged about the darker side of the technology.
Visionary Elon Musk, for one, has described AI as summoning the demon and it could be humanitys biggest existential threat, according to a
video posting
in the Washington Post of his presentation at MIT.
(Source:
iStock
)
And Google DeepMind, creator of AlphaGo, and Stuart Armstrong, an Alexander Tamas Programme on AI Safety research fellow at Oxford University, warned of the need for a red button to disable an AI agent if it learned to avoid being interrupted or stopped by its operator in their report,
Safely Interruptible Agents
.
Should IT security professionals be worried about machine learning and AI potentially becoming the new insider threat?
AI researchers, including Armstrong and Shahar Avin, a research associate with Cambridge Universitys Centre for the Study of Existential Risk and co-author of
The Malicious Use of Artificial Intelligence: Forecasting, Prevention, and Mitigation
, and Sam Bouso, CEO of Precognitive, an IT security company that uses machine learning and AI, weigh in on this issue.
Near-term outlook
AI is not likely to emerge as a new intentional insider threat in the near term, experts say, pointing to several factors at play.
I dont see why AI is specifically an insider threat. In the short term, AI could amplify the capabilities of bad actors and possibly of good actors, whether or not they are insiders or not. In the medium term, AI could automate social engineering approaches such as spear phishing, but thats not specifically an insider threat either, Armstrong told Security Now.
Bouso told Security Now that AI is decades away from becoming a credible insider threat, noting that currently the technology is not at a point where it can think on its own and decide between good and bad.
AI and ML are certainly being used for cybercrime but there is someone behind it when it happens, and they have a specific intent to do harm, Bouso said. Any sort of rogue AI is nothing more than bad programming and human error at this point.
Indeed. Avin, in an interview with Security Now, noted that while machine learning and AI systems currently do not have a will of their own, it is up to companies to set the right policies and restrictions in place to guide the machines learning. Unfortunately, that may prove challenging.
We dont yet have robust tools to fully reason through all possible policies the system might take, and so [IT security professionals] should be extra careful with the inputs and outputs connected to such systems, and adversarially test them through red teaming efforts, Avin advised.
The black-box nature of many contemporary AI and machine learning algorithms, coupled with their ability to discover novel behaviors or policies within an environment or goal, should prompt companies to give additional care when introducing them to corporate networks and systems -- especially those that contain sensitive or confidential information, Avin noted.
And although IT security folks are concerned and discuss AI and its potential for self-awareness and malicious intent, Bouso said its viewed along the lines of one day this could happen.
Long-term outlook
Although cyber attackers are currently using machine learning and AI to wage war on companies and consumers, future development of the technology may one day lead to these technologies becoming IT security professionals frenemies.
Deploying malicious code seems to be an extreme end, and unlikely until we have much more capable systems which are much more trusted, Avin said. However, it is not unreasonable that a Q&A system will disclose information it was not intended to disclose, or, perhaps more worryingly, an automated configuration generator will create configs that exploit edge cases in the system being configured, such that a metric is maximized, but the system itself fails.
Researchers are focused on further machine learning and AI enhancements to make capable systems that are more trusted, a move the security industry is clamoring for as it faces a steep shortage of workers and fatigue from a constant barrage of alerts from their security operations center (SOC).
Development is underway for artificial general intelligences (AGIs), as an example.
Before we get true AGIs, I expect any bugs created by AIs to be minor and non-deliberate. If and when AIs become AGIs, then I expect them to have enough knowledge and learning abilities to deploy malicious code if motivated to do that -- it would have most of the capabilities of humans, and be better in many areas, Armstrong said. But as I said before, if we assume true AGIs, then civilization will be radically changed anyway.
Related posts:
Fortnite Players Lob Shots at Epic Games Over Hacked Accounts
Majority of Healthcare Companies Suffer a Data Breach
Why 46% of Companies Keep Security Strategies Status Quo After an Attack
— Dawn Kawamoto is an award-winning technology and business journalist, whose work has appeared in CNETs News.com, Dark Reading, TheStreet.com, AOLs DailyFinance, and The Motley Fool
.

Last News
▸ ArcSight prepares for future at user conference post HP acquisition. ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Samsung Epic 4G: First To Use Media Hub ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security	▸ Many third-party software fails security tests ◂ Discovered: 07/01/2025 Category: security

**Cyber Security Categories**
Google Dorks Database	Exploits Vulnerability	Exploit Shellcodes

CVE List

Tools/Apps